Cleveland Browns star quarterback Deshaun Watson underwent surgery Thursday after a relapse to his right Achilles tendon. This injury, which occurred after discomfort felt in his ankle, puts his participation in the 2025 season in great danger. Early estimates indicate a recovery period of at least seven months, according to sources close to the team.
A relapse that complicates an already weakened career
This new episode marks the second rupture of the right Achilles tendon for Watson in the space of a few months, his first injury dating from October 2024. The 29-year-old had already experienced a shortened season in 2023, after an operation the shoulder that had kept him sidelined for eight games. This succession of injuries leaves doubts about his ability to return to his best level.
Deshaun Watson: a heavy contract for Cleveland
Since his arrival in Cleveland in 2022, Watson has struggled to justify the Browns' colossal investment. Acquired for three first-round picks and signed to a five-year, fully guaranteed $230 million contract, he represents a significant drain on the team's salary cap. With financial impacts reaching $72.9 million in 2025 and 2026, the Browns must juggle sporting and budgetary imperatives.
In just 19 games played since his arrival, Watson has failed to live up to expectations. His 2024 season ended on a sour note: He had the lowest overall rating in the NFL before his injury.
What future for the Browns at the quarterback position?
As the Browns need to rebuild their offensive future, Watson's uncertain return poses serious questions. Could the franchise select a quarterback in the next draft with the 2nd overall pick? Or will it seek to restructure its squad to maximize performance while awaiting a possible return of its star player? Despite this delicate situation, general manager Andrew Berry wants to be reassuring: Watson's injury will not disrupt the team's plans for the offseason.
Currently, Dorian Thompson-Robinson is the only quarterback under contract for 2025. The 2023 rookie, however, showed limits during his two starts. For their part, Jameis Winston and Bailey Zappe, both free agents, could be reinstated, but nothing is certain yet.
Deshaun Watson's future remains unclear, but his impact on the Browns' strategy and finances will be crucial in the months to come. The next few decisions will determine whether Cleveland can finally bounce back after several disappointing seasons.
